These minutes can be downloaded from http://oxvox.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/OxVoxAGM2025MinutesFinal.pdf
OXVOX AGM – 17 July 2025, 7.00pm, OXTWO, Summertown
MINUTES
1. Welcome and introductory remarks
OxVox Chair Paul Peros (PP) began by welcoming and thanking those attending for coming to a meeting on a weekday evening, which unfortunately had coincided with the England Women’s team playing in the Euros: and more generally he thanked all our members for their support. He commented that members’ opinions steer what OxVox does, and these events are massively important to us. As well as PP, Maurice Earp (ME), Ben Heath (BH), Trevor Lambert (TL), Tim Rosser (TR), and Ali Wolfe (AW) from the trust committee were present and the other committee members and six other trust members had sent their apologies.
We planned to hold this AGM earlier following the end of the 2024/5 season, but we had difficulty finding an affordable venue and were delighted when OxVox member Graeme and colleagues at OXTWO kindly offered us their meeting room without charge. It was important to us to hold the meeting before the start of the new season, to give the refreshed trust committee a clear run in the coming weeks and months.
PP briefly outlined a few of our activities during the past year. As was the case last year, the year had been dominated by the many meetings and activities around support for the new stadium at the Triangle, with fundraising for the Joey Beauchamp Foundation being a feature of the year.
He would give more detail later in the meeting.
2. Result of election of Board members and approval of new members
PP stressed the importance of having an evolving committee and the likelihood that several longstanding and senior members would in due course leave and allow renewal to take place and the trust to grow with new ideas and projects. In this regard it was encouraging this year that efforts to recruit new members had been successful and four new members – Mark Carpenter, Stuart McRae, Matthew O’Donoghue, and Tim Rosser, had come forward. They were joined by re-applications by TL and ME whose periods of membership had expired.
For the past year we had been running light with seven elected members (ME, TL, PP, AW, BH, Jemma Hayward (JH), Michelle Young (MY), and one co-opted member Chris Davies (CD)), relative to our permitted ten elected and two co-opted. With JH becoming a co-optee, the four new members would restore our elected strength to ten and our co-optees to two.
Because the number of candidates for the elected positions was not greater than the number of vacancies, no voting of the membership had been required. Members had been notified of this by email following the closing date for applications.
PP confirmed that in lieu of a membership vote, our rules required that the four new candidates plus returners TL and ME must be approved at the AGM by a majority vote. This was done om a show of hands (proposer: Mark Sargeant) with unanimous approval.
3. Treasurer’s report and accounts
TL covered the OxVox accounts for the year to 30 September 2024, which had been distributed to members some time ago. In brief, they showed an operating excess of £753 over the year on a turnover of £4,549. The main income sources were membership fees of £2,084, Joey Beauchamp Foundation donations of £1,973, and sponsorship from NH Doors of £280 (kindly arranged by ME) to pay for membership cards. Main outgoings were £2,200 to the Joey Beauchamp Foundation (including a pre-agreed donation from our funds), software website and survey fees totalling £911, and printing and stationery costs of £540. The trust had assets of £13,985 at the year end and no creditors.
4. Resolution – Independent Examination of accounts for the 2026 AGM
Nicole Bateman had kindly conducted an independent examination of the accounts as she had in previous years, waiving her fee. We are very grateful for her help. To continue to undertake an independent examination rather than a full audit each year, the AGM must annually pass a resolution to accept this for the next year. The details of this are appended to these minutes. A motion to do so for 2025-6 (proposer: Mark Sargeant) was carried unanimously.]
5. Performance report and projects
PP spoke in more detail about activities undertaken during the year. As mentioned previously, it had been dominated by work on the stadium, meeting club officials, councillors, and representatives of many stakeholders in the application process, and attending public meetings including speaking at a City Council meeting on the stadium. The trust had released many updates describing progress and challenging opponents of the project.
OxVox had also taken part in the process, with the club, the FSA, and OUSP to establish the Fan Advisory Board (FAB) and will have three seats on the FAB when it begins.
We have also supported the Joey Beauchamp Foundation and the Community Trust.
PP gave a verbal report of these issues as follows.
FAB
When the club raised the idea of a Fan Advisory Board we had some major reservations. We were concerned that by having three supporters’ groups (FAB, OUSP, and OxVox), as seemed to be the original plan, the club could negate the strength of all of them and effectively sideline anyone that opposed or questioned them on certain issues.
We took opinions from members and supporters and many members shared our concerns. At the time the club delayed the launch and effectively shelved plans until it was reviewed.
The next contact we had, almost a year later, was an invitation to discuss a revised plan with the club, OUSP and the Football Supporters Association (FSA).
Fundamentally the biggest change was that now OUSP will be disbanding on the creation of the Fan Advisory Board, with many of their hard-working committee joining the FAB.
OxVox were offered, and have accepted, three permanent places on the board allowing members to have full access and feedback.
We negotiated with the club a guarantee that the level and frequency of meetings we now have with the Chairman, CEO, and various members of the club, including our yearly financial review and discussion, remain. We also agreed that OxVox would continue to be the supporters group that dealt with immediate issues that arose and required a quicker response from the club, with the FAB meeting more infrequently.
There was also a clearer definition of the role of the FAB with emphasis on more long-term strategic planning and consultation with the club. A good example of this will be the regular process of discussing ticket pricing and fans’ experiences.
Season tickets
Our season ticket discussions with the club were undertaken jointly with OUSP, as we agreed that having the club review the issue with both of us was a waste of resources for both us and the club.
While there were teething issues, we were able to liaise well together and provided a comprehensive overview of what supporters wanted and the issues from last year.
One of the key issues was the need to start the process earlier, and having time with the club to feed back members’ and supporters’ comments from the last year.
In fairness to the club, they listened and adapted and put together what we feel is a very competitive and comprehensive season ticket package, which has not taken advantage of our Championship status to overcharge a fanbase that have followed them through much harder times.
New stadium
We have of course been continuing our hard work on the new stadium project. While it is of course frustrating and concerning when delays arise, we and the club are confident we are in an excellent position. While we can’t release every detail, most of what we and the club have been involved in is well documented.
We continue to speak with councillors and key stakeholders, but more importantly with members and supporters, making sure this positive campaign continues. We feel we are in an incredibly strong position which we hope will lead to a positive end.
Charity
We continue to support various charities, particularly Oxford United in the Community and the Joey Beauchamp Foundation, and with the addition of new committee members we hope to expand that activity further.
6. Close of AGM
The formal business of the AGM concluded at 7.35pm and the meeting turned to a Q&A session.
Q&A Session
Will there be a club AGM this year?
PP had heard nothing but will follow this up with the club.
When will there be a fans forum?
PP said the club has agreed to hold one early in the season and we are in the process of tying the club down to dates and content.
What do you think about open days? (The questioner said that in his opinion open days should happen in pre-season every year.)
PP agrees that a pre-season open day is a good and popular curtain raiser to the season. Work at the training ground to remediate the effects of the flood, and to enhance the facilities, is nearing completion. An open day at the training ground would be an ideal way to allow interested fans to view the facility, but the moment is not quite right with work still going on. AW added that it is an impressive facility which needs showcasing to the fan base, and we have said to the club that everyone who has seen it has come away heartened by the investment and care in the design, but the club’s view is that it is best to wait a little longer until work is finished.
Is there a thaw in relations with Firoz Kassam?
PP felt that there was an improvement in relations between the club and stadium company, and that access to the stadium for club staff had become less restrictive, for example in terms of hours of access on match days. Communications and understanding between the two bodies had also taken a turn for the better, though the club was still working to an onerous contract – for example, the use of the various rooms on match days remained limited. The trust was disappointed that no lounge or bar access packages had been negotiated and put in place. We had repeatedly made the point that establishing such packages now would be wise, as it would create a bank of subscribers who would like a similar option at the Triangle.
Has the rent increased under the lease extension recently negotiated?
PP didn’t know.
What are the owners’ ultimate aims for OUFC and more broadly?
PP and AW have had several meetings with Grant Ferguson in which this has been a topic of conversation. Eric Thohir and Anindya Bakrie clearly see massive potential both in terms of growing OUFC and in terms of growing an asset using the Oxford association and ‘brand’ which is known worldwide, and commercial developments around the stadium, most obviously the hotel. The club’s profile having been raised massively in Indonesia around the pre-season President’s Cup has had a knock-on effect in raising Indonesian football’s profile internationally. The Championship is a league known worldwide and the synergies of the various factors should not be underestimated.
AW added that, having travelled to the President’s Cup, whatever the reservations about football-related aspects, the massive publicity achieved by the club’s participation, in a country which has the fourth largest population in the world, was remarkable. Romeny and Ferdinan were household names, their images were everywhere, and embryonic OUFC supporters’ clubs were being set up.
Will we be in trouble on financial fair play?
BH had spent time looking at the club finances and the rules in this area. Championship clubs were allowed an accumulated loss of £39m over 3 seasons. Although the recent decision to require the preparatory stadium related spend to be on the books had increased the reported loss last year, it is anticipated that the club will meet the financial fair play requirements.
What do you know about how the stadium will be paid for?
PP said that the detailed makeup of the funding model was not clear at this point but would become much more evident following a positive planning decision. It was clear that the planned hotel will be a massive asset given the demand in Oxford for hotel space and the extreme difficulty in finding development land in the area.
What can we ‘give back’ to the Indonesians?
AW felt that the pre-season in Indonesia, the work of players and staff with local children, and the presence of the club in the tournament, with our own BBC Oxford and Oxford Mail colleagues reporting, was important in establishing real links with that country and its people. It was much more effective than might have been expected and Eric Thohir was reportedly delighted. There is a basis to build on.
Finally, how would you summarise the state of things at OUFC?
PP appreciated that the fact that some long standing members of staff were reported to have left the club recently was potentially a matter of concern, and we should safeguard the soul of the club as it changes, it was a fact that people leave at all clubs from time to time and it would be wrong to read too much into it. The club as things stand is in a healthy position and we keenly await a positive planning decision on the stadium at the end of the month.
Finally, PP thanked everyone again for attending, and the meeting closed at approximately 8.20pm.
OXVOX AGM 2025 – RESOLUTION (agenda item 3)
It is hereby resolved that subject to the provisions of section 4a of the 1968 Friendly and Industrial and Provident Societies Act, the members of the Society shall not require an audit for the accounts covering the financial year ending on 30 September 2025, when they are presented to the next AGM held in 2026.
The members of the society agree that the accounts for the financial year ending on 30 September 2025 and for which reports will be laid before the following AGM do not require a full audit provided that:
1. The total income for that year does not exceed the threshold laid down by FSA/Supporters Direct for audit exemption (currently £25,000),
2. An Independent Examination of those accounts is carried out in place of the full Audit,
3. The Independent Examination is carried out in line with the best practice of FSA/Supporters Direct as set out in the Guidance Notes,
4. A report from the Independent Examiner is included within the Accounts and circulated to members.
The Society notes that
1. The Independent Examination does not carry the same weight as a full Audit,
2. The members of the Trust instruct the Board to identify a suitably qualified practitioner to undertake the review,
3. The Board shall agree the appointment of the examiner and shall agree the terms of that appointment in writing,
4. FSA/Supporters Direct has no liability in respect of any Trust Accounts,
5. FSA/Supporters Direct will use the report of an Independent Examiner when considering your Trust’s eligibility for membership as against criteria in its membership policy.
Note: This resolution must be passed by 80% of the members voting in person and by proxy, and only comes into force if it is passed by that margin AND the numbers voting against do not equal more than 10% of those members eligible to vote.
